A year ago, I taught a class on middle school reading instruction at the university I'm attending for my PhD. In the class was a woman I spent a great deal of time wondering why in the world she was spending piles of money to attend a program in which she had no interest in learning anything. Every single topic and related discussion was met with, "well, that won't work" or "my students can't do that" or "no one really does that." Even when met with the lived experiences of myself and others in the class, she was steadfast in her opposition. She had nothing positive to say the entire semester about students, teaching, learning, school, education, life. If this was her disposition in her own classroom, I was sad for students in her classes.
I have never been more drained as a teacher trying to acknowledge her and validate her opinions while also presenting the opposing viewpoint. I don't think she felt as though her view was very well respected in the class - many students in the class continually argued with her and though I tried my best to be neutral, it was clear I did not agree with her negativity about absolutely everything we discussed.
I was a little surprised to see her in the class in which I gave a talk yesterday. But there she was, front row, center. And it was as if she followed the script I could have written for the conversation.
Me: So it's really important as a literacy coach to work with the teachers' agendas, rather than pushing your own.
Her: But teachers don't want to change.
Me: Actually in my experience, I haven't found that to be true. Given the right context, I believe and have seen lots of teachers who others may have written off interested in making important shifts in their instruction.
Her: But teachers close to retirement aren't going to make a change. Why should they? They're almost done. I wouldn't.
Me: I worked with a teacher who got her National Board certification in the year she retired. There is no set trajectory for teachers.
Her: Well, I just don't think that's true.
Sigh. This is what it was like for 3.5 hours every week for an entire semester. She is on the very, very limited list of students I was not sorry to see walk out of the classroom on the last day (I hate to admit that such a list exists, but let's be real). It was exhausting trying to be respectful of her opinions to maintain a positive environment for her learning and for the sake of a safe classroom environment. I worked really hard to help her see the possibilities of teaching and learning rather than her incessant need to play devil's advocate and desire to derail the education of the other members of class. I guess I learned a lot from her in that way. And she will not be the last like her I encounter. But once again, I wasn't sad at the end of the class.